
What the permit doesn't see
Bringing environmental health into land-use decisions in Indonesia’s Gorontalo Province
Land-use decisions are often made without a clear picture of their environmental consequences. Carefully chosen, context-specific indicators can bring these hidden consequences into view. Agricultural and other land-use planners and developers can use them to make more informed and evidence-based decisions which take environmental sustainability and its associated social and economic benefits into account. In regions facing severe sustainability challenges and a growing extent of critical land - land so degraded that its ecological and productive functions are severely impaired – there is an urgent need to systematically embed monitoring of environment health into land-use planning. Biodiversity condition indexes can be utilised as context appropriate proxies for environmental health.
Between 2001 and 2024, Gorontalo Province reportedly lost approximately 145,000 hectares of forest or tree cover, much of it associated with agricultural expansion (Global Forest Watch, 2025). In addition, more than 82,000 hectares of land within forest areas are currently classified as critical land (DLHK Gorontalo Province Strategic Plan 2025-2029). The loss of the province’s forests is intensifying environmental instability, reducing the natural carbon storage capacity of the landscape and eroding soil. The resulting increase in vulnerability to flooding, landslides and droughts is damaging the resilience and productivity of the province’s agriculture. Yet the province’s social and economic challenges - including high rates of poverty and unemployment - continue to drive patterns of agricultural development which damage the environmental foundations of agriculture in the long-term.
With reliable environmental health data, appropriate institutional capacity, and planning and licensing systems that put this data to use, Gorontalo and comparable regions could take practical steps to ensure future development complements conservation priorities and the evolution of investment agendas for sustainable land use. This could begin with halting unsuitable development in critical priority areas, integrating biodiversity condition indexes into environmental assessments and spatial plans, restoring degraded ecosystems, and encouraging sustainable enterprises including community-based ecotourism, ecological restoration enterprises, climate-resilient agroforestry, and biodiversity-friendly agricultural production. Such measures would help ensure that future economic development strengthens, rather than undermines, the ecological foundations of regional prosperity. The province’s own online investment licensing system, the Gorontalo Online Single Submission Okey (GOSSO), offers a ready-made entry point.
What would an environmental health-based land-use planning system look like?
Priority critical land conditions as the benchmarks
Critical land within Gorontalo’s forest areas now exceeds 82,000 hectares, much of it at forest margins where the economic pressure to expand agriculture is greatest. The first step is to identify priority critical land within ecologically significant forest areas and watersheds, and to use its characteristics to set baseline benchmarks against which suitability for development as opposed to conservation and restoration can be considered on a strong evidence basis in each case.
These baselines would focus on forest margins, wildlife corridors, watersheds, and habitats supporting endemic Wallacean species. This matters because Gorontalo lies within Wallacea, a globally significant centre of endemism facing increasing forest loss and fragmentation (Voigt et al., 2021). Against these benchmarks, planning units could be classified for strict conservation, ecological restoration, sustainable agroforestry, or controlled development according to measurable ecological thresholds.
Context-specific proxies for environmental health
A context-specific index incorporating socio-ecological conditions could be developed, in this case for Gorontalo Province. Rather than relying on specialist species surveys, it uses observable, low-cost proxies that local agencies and communities can collect themselves, such as crop diversity, river turbidity and the frequency of human–wildlife conflict. Our proposed index includes land cover and vegetation diversity, agro-biodiversity, fauna conditions and human-wildlife interactions, supporting ecosystem quality, biodiversity-based conservation practices, and the socio-cultural functions of biodiversity, as set out in the table below. Lower scores across these components would indicate poorer environmental health, greater ecological degradation and weaker conservation capacity. The index could therefore be used to monitor sustainability impacts, and identify areas requiring protection, restoration, or biodiversity-compatible agroforestry.
Making GOSSO a green development instrument
To tackle persistent rural poverty, the Government of Gorontalo Province launched the Gorontalo Online Single Submission Okey (GOSSO) licensing system, designed to simplify permitting and attract the investment the province needs for jobs and growth. But faster licensing without environmental safeguards carries a real risk: it can speed up the conversion of forests to plantations, mining and infrastructure, fragmenting habitats and adding to the province’s already extensive critical land.
GOSSO is also the point where environmental health data could make the biggest difference. Under a “One Data” policy, the condition index and critical-land baselines could be built directly into the licensing process, so investment proposals are assessed against the environmental health of the land they would affect. Proposals in protected forests or high conservation value areas would face stricter requirements or rejection, while activities that support environmental health, such as agroforestry, ecosystem restoration and community-based ecotourism, could be prioritised. In this way GOSSO could become an intelligent green development instrument, rather than a gateway for environmental degradation.
Implications for policy and planning
None of this will work without the people to use it. Gorontalo has too few forest rangers and extension officers for the size of its forest estate, and following budget adjustments in 2024, only 598 of the 7,094 hectares of critical land identified for rehabilitation were rehabilitated. Investment in human resources, including training in spatial data and biodiversity management, is therefore as important as the indicators themselves.
Alongside this investment in people, these steps represent one potential transformational approach to effectively deploying biodiversity condition indices at scale - complementing efforts to incentivise development - across land-use planning and monitoring systems. When integrated into land-use planning, licensing, environmental assessment, and monitoring systems, these indicators could provide a consistent basis for evaluating ecological risks, identifying restoration priorities, and directing investment away from environmentally sensitive areas. This approach would complement existing efforts to accelerate economic development by ensuring that incentives, permits, and infrastructure decisions are aligned with measurable environmental health objectives. At scale, such integration could transform environmental data from a largely descriptive resource into an operational instrument for evidence-based planning, regulatory oversight, and adaptive landscape management. The same approach could be adapted by other regions facing similar pressure to grow their economies at the forest frontier.
References
Dinas LHK Provinsi Gorontalo. 2025. Rencana Strategis Dinas Lingkungan Hidup dan Kehutanan Provinsi Gorontalo. Pemerintah Provinsi Gorontalo (unpublished)
Global Forest Watch. (2025). Interactive World Forest Map & Tree Cover Change Data | GFW. World Resources Institute. Accessed on 23 October 2025: https://www.globalforestwatch.org/map/
Sirajuddin, Z., Dunggio, I., & Ayshari, A. T. (2026, February). Leveraging biodiversity indicators for sustainable environmental management in Gorontalo Province. LEAF Indonesia, Global Centre on Biodiversity for Climate (GCBC), RG2-009569. UPDATE
Voigt, M., Supriatna, J., Deere, N. J., et al. (2021). Emerging threats from deforestation and forest fragmentation in the Wallacea centre of endemism. Environmental Research Letters, 16(9), 094048. DOI 10.1088/1748-9326/ac15cd.
